How to change your subscription hero
Updated October 29, 2026 · 3 min read
For a magicstory.com subscription, open Account > Subscriptions, open the subscription, and select Change who stars to choose another eligible saved character. Use Change look to update the current hero. App-store members can contact support for help choosing a hero when using a credit.
For subscriptions billed directly on magicstory.com, Change who stars picks a different saved character for future books. Change look changes the current hero's appearance.
App Store, Google Play, and Amazon Appstore memberships do not have these controls. See the app-store section below for help choosing a hero.
Open the subscription
Sign in, go to Account > Subscriptions, and select Manage subscription on the child's card. The subscription page shows the current hero.
Select Change who stars
Choose Change who stars next to the hero's picture.
Pick a saved character
Choose from the eligible characters shown. The current hero is marked Current hero. Only characters with the art style required by the upcoming book are shown. If the character you want is missing, see the guidance below before creating another one.
Confirm your choice
Select Switch to with the character's name. They become the hero for this subscription's books, starting with the next one.
Why is a saved character missing?
Theo heroes work with Theo books. Other books need a separate 3D hero created from your child's photo. The picker explains which art style the subscription needs.
If Show more heroes is available, check the rest of your saved characters first. If there are no matching heroes, use Open a matching book when offered to create one in the required style, or Create a hero for a 3D character. Then return to the subscription and switch. If the picker cannot verify eligible heroes or load your saved characters, retry or contact us.
How do I update the current hero's appearance?
Select Change look next to the hero's picture on the subscription page. This opens the look studio, where you can change things like hair or clothes without picking a different character. See how to change your child's look for the steps.
You cannot change the hero or their look while the next book is already being made. The subscription page tells you when that is the case.
What if two saved characters are the same child?
When the current and selected heroes have the same first name and a compatible art style, you will be asked whether they are the same child. Choose Yes, same child to combine the characters, use the new look, and keep their books and progress together. This cannot be undone.
If they are different children with the same name, choose No, a different child. The subscription will switch to the character you selected.
Does this change an order I already placed?
No. Changing the subscription hero applies only to future orders. An existing order keeps its original character, even if it has not shipped yet.
To change the next story instead, see how to choose a different story.
What if I subscribed through the App Store, Google Play, or Amazon?
These memberships do not have a saved subscription hero. Account > Subscriptions shows your membership status and credits instead.
Credit redemption is not currently available from your account. Contact us for help choosing the hero for your next book.
Questions parents ask
What's the difference between Change who stars and Change look?
Change who stars picks a different saved character for the books. Change look keeps the same hero and updates how they look, such as their hair or outfit.
Why is Change who stars missing from my app-store membership?
App-store memberships do not have a saved subscription hero. Contact support for help choosing a hero when using a credit for your next book.
Was this article helpful?
Still stuck? Our team has your back.
Talk it through with our AI voice assistant or send a message to our support team.